Over 1M Posts • 84K Topics • 9K Authors

what car would you rather choose? - 6G Celicas Forums

Topic #63932 28 posts Started by bccentaur3
90+ 300zx
b5 96-2001 A4
Hopefully an alltrac 165 or 185 I don't really care, but I would rather want a 165.


give your reasoning to why you would choose that vehicle and why you wouldn't chose the other.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!
i would take an ST185 over a ST165 every day and twice on sunday.

i would never get a 300ZX, they have serious head gasket issues similar to the 7M-GTE

2001 Celica GT-S Turbo1997 Supra TT 6speed1997 Celica 3MZ/1MZ swap1990 Celica All-Trac
Unless its a low mileage Audi, that's going to be trouble.

MyFlickrMyeBay_Perpetual Aperture_
Its too much a question of taste.

I would get a 300zx knowing it would be a garage queen. It would be the most fun to drive IMO, or at least the most challenging. The fun thing about anything Nissan though, is if you end up hating the stock engine there's like 40,000 other engines you can swap in. I've also heard of people swapping LS1s into their 300ZX.

the ST165 and ST185 are amazing. Personally I think the ST165 looks a little more bad-ass, and it fits my tastes. However good lucky finding one. The sad fate of Japanese cars that old is that they've suffered the fate of daily drivers. Nobody would tell you in 1986 that the import scene would explode (and that this car would have more of a value than a Camaro or Mustang for example). If you find a 185 you should settle for that.

Never driven an Audi and although the A4s are nice, without Quattro written on the back, the are just overpriced Passats. Though there is a huge community in tuning Audi/VW vehicles, the main focus is of course on Quattro models, Audi S models and the lighter smalelr Golf/Jetta GTi. However if you're looking for something a little bit on the side of luxury the A4 is a good choice.

(\__/)(='.'=) This is bunny. Copy and paste bunny into your(")_(") signature to help him gain world domination.
I agree with you ^

The 165 is way badass looking than the 185.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!
All good cars. Personally I am looking at a Datsun 280z to fix up and be exempt from emissions here in California if my plans for the MR2 do not follow through.

From your selection, I say 165!

91 MR2 Turbo SW20, 92 MR2 Turbo SW20, 95 Celica GT ST204
>
QUOTE (Random_Stranger @ Dec 3, 2008 - 4:10 PM) *
>All good cars. Personally I am looking at a Datsun 280z to fix up and be exempt from emissions here in California if my plans for the MR2 do not follow through.

From your selection, I say 165!


WHY? Why not the 240Z or 260Z.

The 280s have park benches on them. You know, those big massive bumpers the 280Z had to meet US safety requirements when the S30 lineup was refreshed. I can see how you would want the L28 but I think any potential speed you will make up will be lost by the added weight of those chrome monstrosities on the front and back. Still, anything S30 is still a beautiful car. If you get one, you should make your first mod adding a seatbelt to the front bumper, so you can drive an extra couple of friends around on it wink.gif

This post has been edited by Taskbot: Dec 3, 2008 - 5:32 PM

(\__/)(='.'=) This is bunny. Copy and paste bunny into your(")_(") signature to help him gain world domination.
Wow - I've never seen so many people favor the ST-165 over the ST-185 before. I used to own a ST-16x and trust me when I say the interior is not something I could ever be happy with again. To me the ST-185 also looks a hell of alot better but tat's mearly aesthetics so opinions will vary.

ENGINE: '93 RC 3S-GTE/WRC CT-20b [18-20PSI]PERF: TRD/HKS/ARP/NGK/MSD/ACT/Blitz/STRI/APEX'i/TwosRus/GReddy/Magnaflo/KOYOSUSP: Tein/Bilstein/SusTech/INT: SS-III SEATS/Toyota Hyper SportsEXT: WRC/TRD/404QUOTE (lagos @ Aug 25, 2010 - 10:13 AM)Its a safety feature so that people like you don't end up killing themselves or everyone around them.Slow down Paul Walker.6GC Chat - Go there: [url="http://www.griffgirl.com/forum/chat/index.php[/url]
I just like the 165. Nothing about screams I will beat you. Just look at the 185 and 205's. They look scary and can do what ever they want to you. 165 is a total sleeper. Think about it. a 3rd gen swap with the 3rd gen rear diff. You can call it a day.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!
300zx - no way. too many problems, especially the aforementioned head gasket issue.
A4 - if you can afford the repair bill....
Alltrac - neither. Both are old and breaking. Rust is an issue, and so are replacement parts. I have a few friends with alltracs and they all agree that their cars (some mildly modified, two with 205 swaps) are broken 3/4 of the time.


now a 98-01 2.5rs with a wrx or sti swap....mmmmmmmm

1991 MR2 - T-tops - Crimson Red - Gen3 3SGTE - Lots of moneyI'm not really an asshole, but I play one on the internet.**** Photobucket
>
QUOTE (bccentaur3 @ Dec 3, 2008 - 5:23 PM) *
>I just like the 165. Nothing about screams I will beat you. Just look at the 185 and 205's. They look scary and can do what ever they want to you. 165 is a total sleeper. Think about it. a 3rd gen swap with the 3rd gen rear diff. You can call it a day.

Very true.

ENGINE: '93 RC 3S-GTE/WRC CT-20b [18-20PSI]PERF: TRD/HKS/ARP/NGK/MSD/ACT/Blitz/STRI/APEX'i/TwosRus/GReddy/Magnaflo/KOYOSUSP: Tein/Bilstein/SusTech/INT: SS-III SEATS/Toyota Hyper SportsEXT: WRC/TRD/404QUOTE (lagos @ Aug 25, 2010 - 10:13 AM)Its a safety feature so that people like you don't end up killing themselves or everyone around them.Slow down Paul Walker.6GC Chat - Go there: [url="http://www.griffgirl.com/forum/chat/index.php[/url]
when i started my car search i was looking at 300zx's and though they would be a very fun thing to drive, i dont reccomend it if u cant keep up with the maintence on it.
maybe a 2.5RS, sc300, or integra type r?
165+4th gen 3s= pure sex

I would take the 165 even with the first gen motor...would just be badass to build and have fun with....pretty ticked off daftboy didnt bid on the 2 that were on ebay that sold for 1,020!!!!!!...0o well..but yea 165 ftw...unless you can find a clean 300zx tt with low miles thats unmolested(good luck) but thatd be the only other option

I"M NOT A TOYOTA FAN, IM A FANATIC1984 accord hatch 5 speed (T-Belt)-Junkyard1991 VDUB jetta wolfsburg Ed. 5 speed (clutch)-junkyard1988 Dodge Aries K (sold)1969 Chevy El camino - Traded for celica1991 Dodge Daytona-Traded for Celica1988 Chevy Camaro-Work in Progress1989 Ford Mustang LX 5.0 - For Sale1995 Toyota Celica-Work in Progress
165 Is a great looking car, Do it!
I think when people say the 185 looks good, they mean it's hood looks good. The rest of the car is oogly.
I wouldn't buy a 300zx w/ over 100k unless I had my own tow-truck thumbsdown.gif .
unless you really own an alltrac & work on it yourself, i don't feel you can comment on it honestly. i'm not a big fan of hear-say.
if you get one, make sure the body is free of rust & make sure it has had important maintenance taken care of on a regular basis.
you will hear a lot of people say they aren't reliable. if kept pretty much stock with regular maintenance, they are reliable -- the probs come when you add mods & kick up the boost on a motor that is 20+ yrs old then the reliability flies out the window.

as far as parts availability, some OEM parts are & have been discontinued by Toyota. what do you expect though? there were never that many alltracs made (165 or 185) so Toyota has no interest in continuing to make a part they may sell 10-20 units per year.
since the 3sgte was available in MKII MR2's engine parts are no problem, just unique alltrac parts become a bit more challenging - be ready to be persistent.

in conclusion, you better be willing ready & able to work on the car in any & all kinds of weather & you better have plenty of tools & a BGB.

an alltrac can be quick, but you better have some deep pockets to get it there.
as much as i love the car, there are plenty of newer cars that are a lot faster & take a lot less to get there.
if you're willing to make the commitment, good for you, but it's not for the faint of heart ... i can say that honestly.

to the guy above that said ST185's are oogly, i'd be willing to bet money you've never seen a real one in person else you wouldn't say that wink.gif

'87 AW11 MR2 "Super R2" 4AG-ZE swapped Stage 1 Complete'90 ST185 Celica All-Trac 3S-GTE "Vadar" Turbo AWD Sith Stage 2 in the works'99 SXV20 Camry 5S-FE "Darth Maul" TRD Grocery Getter powah coming soon
St185's are sexy, but its too stout. It looks like a bully just like the 205. But like I said the 165 is just a plain jane. I am up to the challenge and I want to stay in the toyota family. Just look at my car, I've worked on it at 3AM, outside in -10 degree weather, swapping in the rain. I've done all kinds of things with my car.

I might also consider the 2.5rs. Again I could careless how slow they are. I live in MN for petes sake. Snow is my friend.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!
185 i would choose smile.gif

[b]My Build Thread|Flickr|My Blog
to the guy above that said ST185's are oogly, i'd be willing to bet money you've never seen a real one in person else you wouldn't say that wink.gif

I almost bought one but after further inspection I noticed some mechanical problems that might bite me down the road. Looks are a matter of taste and my taste is that the 185 doesn't compare to the 165 and 205 visually
What??? To the guy above. 185 looking better than 205??? You are crazy sir. You sir probably havent seen a 205 in person or a 205 conversion hahahaha.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!
>
QUOTE (Taskbot @ Dec 3, 2008 - 2:31 PM) *
>>
QUOTE (Random_Stranger @ Dec 3, 2008 - 4:10 PM) *
>All good cars. Personally I am looking at a Datsun 280z to fix up and be exempt from emissions here in California if my plans for the MR2 do not follow through.

From your selection, I say 165!


WHY? Why not the 240Z or 260Z.

The 280s have park benches on them. You know, those big massive bumpers the 280Z had to meet US safety requirements when the S30 lineup was refreshed. I can see how you would want the L28 but I think any potential speed you will make up will be lost by the added weight of those chrome monstrosities on the front and back. Still, anything S30 is still a beautiful car. If you get one, you should make your first mod adding a seatbelt to the front bumper, so you can drive an extra couple of friends around on it wink.gif



You can remove it, can't you? I believe I have seen it done. Ok, maybe 260z, but still want 280z and wouldn't mind doing some body work to it.

Sorry to be off topic.

91 MR2 Turbo SW20, 92 MR2 Turbo SW20, 95 Celica GT ST204
its okay, its an off topic thread hahaha.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!
>
QUOTE (darthripley @ Dec 3, 2008 - 10:03 PM) *
>unless you really own an alltrac & work on it yourself, i don't feel you can comment on it honestly. i'm not a big fan of hear-say.
if you get one, make sure the body is free of rust & make sure it has had important maintenance taken care of on a regular basis.
you will hear a lot of people say they aren't reliable. if kept pretty much stock with regular maintenance, they are reliable -- the probs come when you add mods & kick up the boost on a motor that is 20+ yrs old then the reliability flies out the window.

as far as parts availability, some OEM parts are & have been discontinued by Toyota. what do you expect though? there were never that many alltracs made (165 or 185) so Toyota has no interest in continuing to make a part they may sell 10-20 units per year.
since the 3sgte was available in MKII MR2's engine parts are no problem, just unique alltrac parts become a bit more challenging - be ready to be persistent.

in conclusion, you better be willing ready & able to work on the car in any & all kinds of weather & you better have plenty of tools & a BGB.

an alltrac can be quick, but you better have some deep pockets to get it there.
as much as i love the car, there are plenty of newer cars that are a lot faster & take a lot less to get there.
if you're willing to make the commitment, good for you, but it's not for the faint of heart ... i can say that honestly.

to the guy above that said ST185's are oogly, i'd be willing to bet money you've never seen a real one in person else you wouldn't say that wink.gif


lol dude...st185's are hidious...at least the 4th gen had some nice lines to it..i would pick a 165 over a 185 anyday...plus i would want a 1st gen 3s..i think the body style of the 185 is just weid looking...i dunno...6th gens rule everything though

I"M NOT A TOYOTA FAN, IM A FANATIC1984 accord hatch 5 speed (T-Belt)-Junkyard1991 VDUB jetta wolfsburg Ed. 5 speed (clutch)-junkyard1988 Dodge Aries K (sold)1969 Chevy El camino - Traded for celica1991 Dodge Daytona-Traded for Celica1988 Chevy Camaro-Work in Progress1989 Ford Mustang LX 5.0 - For Sale1995 Toyota Celica-Work in Progress
>
QUOTE (95st-celica @ Dec 4, 2008 - 2:27 AM) *
>lol dude...st185's are hidious...at least the 4th gen had some nice lines to it..i would pick a 165 over a 185 anyday...plus i would want a 1st gen 3s..i think the body style of the 185 is just weid looking...i dunno...6th gens rule everything though


First, i'm a girl so nice try.
Second, saying you want a 1st gen 3sgte shows just how much you know about the motor.
Third, everyone's tastes are different - Thank God for that.

OP, glad to hear you're in it for the long haul with an alltrac - good luck in your search.

'87 AW11 MR2 "Super R2" 4AG-ZE swapped Stage 1 Complete'90 ST185 Celica All-Trac 3S-GTE "Vadar" Turbo AWD Sith Stage 2 in the works'99 SXV20 Camry 5S-FE "Darth Maul" TRD Grocery Getter powah coming soon
Thank you.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!
>
QUOTE (bccentaur3 @ Dec 4, 2008 - 10:13 AM) *
>Thank you.



So what are you leaning towards man?

Crap, now Darth is a chick? All these people I am sure are dudes end up being female........ That is crazy....



Anyways, I got more reading to do. For future reference, if I forget to READ when I reply to something, then excuse me. I like to take short breaks as this next week is Finals and for math I have 112 subjects to cover in the next 3 days. So forgive me for not wanting to read pages just to say something. I think I have that right anyways, as a human.

91 MR2 Turbo SW20, 92 MR2 Turbo SW20, 95 Celica GT ST204
To be honest I am leaning towards the 98-01 subaru 2.5RS. I know its not on the list, but its only practical for MN.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!
>
QUOTE (bccentaur3 @ Dec 4, 2008 - 7:53 PM) *
>To be honest I am leaning towards the 98-01 subaru 2.5RS. I know its not on the list, but its only practical for MN.



Good choice as well. I wanted to do something with one of those but they are just too hard for me to find around these parts. If you do decide to go that route, good luck. That 2.5RS just isn't meant for me. So you were seeking something AWD pretty much huh? I want that, but I guess since we don't get snow I can go with something else. I am sure AWD cars would be easier to find out there than there.

91 MR2 Turbo SW20, 92 MR2 Turbo SW20, 95 Celica GT ST204
its actually pretty hard to find up here. Because everyone else owns one hahaha.

98 Celica gt red- totaled deer94 Celica st black DD (bad weather beater)- totaled deer95 Celica gt silver- chassis sold88 Celica All-Trac (Burned to a crisp)94 Celica gt white (sold)In need of a rust free chassis!!!!